Funny? No. Entertainment? No.

Somebody sent me a link to a video. “Watch this,” they said. “It’s SO funny, absolutely hilarious.”

Well, I’m all for hilarity, so settled down happily in anticipation.

As soon as I saw that it was something to do with the X-factor, I began to have doubts. And as I watched, they grew.

A pretty girl, full of confidence, with a huge smile and attitude appears on stage.

She sings a Pink song, clearly believing she’s fantastic, then stands on the stage, facing the judges and waiting for their verdict.

It’s not good. As they deliver their (valid) opinions, her mouth starts to tremble and she is visibly incredulous. She cannot believe they didn’t find her performance great.

But, they give her another chance.

And then they all say “No.”

Her disappointment is painful to see as her smile fades away and her eyes take on the look of a dog that’s just been kicked for no reason it can understand. She loses her rag and goes into tantrum-hyperdrive, flinging the microphone, shouting obscenities.

This unfortunate event happened some time ago – I don’t know exactly when, but certainly not when the show aired on Saturday. So it had been sitting on a shelf gleefully awaiting the opportunity to share it with the world. To humiliate a girl who had already been humiliated at the time, who has humiliated herself, and who must have felt horrified and wounded after the event.

How is this entertainment?

Yes, she behaved badly. But had her hopes been built up by her parents and the show producers, telling her she was as wonderful as she obviously thought she was? I bet they had. I bet she walked onto that stage thinking this was her moment, the first step on the road to the stardom they promised to her. And five minutes later her dreams were shattered and she’d made a fool of herself. The happy, bouncy positive girl is now a wild wreck. There’s something about all this that smacks to me of manipulation.

Not only has her humiliation been witnessed by however many millions of people still watch the X-factor, but she’s being vilified in the press, on Facebook and Twitter.

The whole sorry episode could and should have been left on the cutting floor – but wait! Isn’t it great fodder for the show!

Sorry, it wasn’t funny, and it isn’t entertainment. It’s just sad.




4 thoughts on “Funny? No. Entertainment? No.

  1. Well said, Susie!

    There is too much of this nastiness – of people thinking that by belittling somebody they somehow make themselves look good. Only to others of like mind, I think.

    We have already had the appalling comments of some comedian talking about Rebecca Adlington’s face.

    And Karl Lagerfeld saying he does not like Pippa Middleton’s face! I couldn’t give a toss about Pippa Middleton, but have you seen Karl Lagerfeld’s face? He is seriously weird and no amount of commenting on other people will make him look good. And didn’t he make some disparaging comment about Adele?

  2. Well said!

    People boosting their own egis by deliberately humiliating others seems to be a feature of the ‘entertainment’ now on offer on the box.
    Even on something so anodyne as the Great British Bakeoff there seems to be a great deal of nastiness in the comments made on the contestants…I would prefer technical comment which would be helpful to see what had gone wrong and why.

    I would so like a return to decency and information on the box….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s